top of page
Writer's pictureTayU Yaho

Black Like An Oven: The Argument for Interpreting the Blackness of Lamentation as a Simile

The Book of Lamentations is full of vivid and emotional descriptions of the suffering of the Israelites during the Babylonian siege of Jerusalem. Two specific verses, Lamentations 4:8 and 5:10, mention changes in the appearance of the people's skin. These verses describe their skin as "blacker than a coal" and "black like an oven." While many have interpreted these phrases as metaphors for suffering, I argue that they are similes meant to be taken literally.

 

Understanding Simile and Metaphor

 

To make this argument clear, we need to understand the difference between similes and metaphors:

 

- Simile: A simile compares two different things using connecting words like "as" or "like." It explicitly states that one thing is similar to another. For example, "He fights like a lion" means he fights with the courage or ferocity of a lion.

 

- Metaphor: A metaphor also compares two different things but does so indirectly, without using "as" or "like." It suggests that one thing is another. For instance, "The world is a stage" implies that life is like a play where people act out their roles.

 

Lamentations 5:10 as a Simile

 

In Lamentations 5:10, the phrase "our skin was black like an oven" uses "like" to make a direct comparison. This simile compares the darkening of the skin due to famine with the blackened interior of an oven that has been used continuously. It vividly describes how the skin of the Israelites actually looked during the extreme conditions they faced.

 

Literal Interpretation Supported by Context

 

The context of Lamentations supports a literal interpretation of these similes. The book describes the real and harsh conditions of Jerusalem's siege, including famine, death, and suffering. The detailed descriptions of physical changes are consistent with the literal and dire conditions the people experienced. The simile here serves to concretely describe how extreme famine altered their physical appearance in a noticeable way.

 

Historical and Cultural Relevance

 

Taking these descriptions literally also fits with how physical descriptions were used in biblical times. In ancient writings, detailed descriptions helped readers visualize the conditions being described. This literal interpretation highlights how the physical effects of famine were severe enough to change the appearance of the Israelites' skin.

 

Scholarly Interpretations and Implications

 

While some scholars interpret these descriptions as metaphors for spiritual or emotional suffering, acknowledging the simile’s role in these descriptions supports a literal interpretation. This approach respects the symbolic richness of the text while grounding it in the real, physical experiences of the people. It also encourages a more comprehensive understanding of the text, including the physiological effects of famine as they were understood and recorded in ancient times.

 

Conclusion

 

In conclusion, the use of simile in Lamentations, especially the clear comparison in 5:10, supports interpreting these descriptions as literal changes in the Israelites' skin color during the siege. This reading respects the textual integrity of Lamentations and fits with the historical and descriptive purposes of biblical literature. By taking these descriptions literally, we gain a deeper understanding of the harsh realities faced by the people of Jerusalem, providing a vivid, tangible aspect to the suffering depicted in this sorrowful book.



464 views1 comment

1 Comment


This was an easy read and straightforward. Thank you for sharing!

Like
bottom of page